Erin and Tom have been married seventeen years. They have two children, ages nine and thirteen, and a house both of them want the children to stay in.

The proposed terms are reasonable and, for the most part, agreed. Erin keeps the house so the children stay in their schools. Tom keeps a larger share of his 401(k) to offset his half of the equity. Erin receives spousal support for thirty-six months, plus child support. Within twelve months of the decree, Erin removes Tom from the mortgage. If she cannot, the house is listed for sale.

The agreement is in draft. Three professionals read it. Each one reads it correctly, and each one sees something the other two do not.

Erin and Tom are an illustration, not a client. The terms are typical of files family law professionals see every week.

What the attorney sees

The attorney reads the file as an advocate, and the questions are about rights and remedies. Is this a fair division under the state's law? Is the twelve-month deadline enforceable? If Erin misses it, does the sale provision actually protect Tom, or does he wait another year while his name stays on a loan he no longer controls?

Erin's attorney reads the same paragraph from the other side. Is twelve months long enough? Who controls the listing if the house has to be sold, and at what price?

These are the questions that decide whether the agreement holds up, and only the attorney can answer them. The attorney decides what goes into the agreement and how it is written. Nothing below changes that.

What the Certified Divorce Financial Analyst® sees

The CDFA® reads the file as a long-term financial picture. According to the Institute for Divorce Financial Analysts, CDFA® professionals look at the short- and long-term effects of dividing property, analyze retirement plans, identify the tax consequences of different proposals, and determine whether a client can afford to keep the home.

In Erin's file, that means real questions. Trading her share of the 401(k) for equity in the house leaves her with a larger asset she cannot spend and a smaller retirement. What does her budget look like in month thirty-seven, when spousal support stops? Is keeping the house the right financial choice for her, or only the right emotional one?

A good CDFA® asks whether Erin can afford the house. That question belongs to them, and it is an important one.

What the Certified Divorce Lending Professional® sees

The CDLP® reads the file and asks one question: can the plan for the house be carried out as the agreement describes it, and if not, what does the agreement need to say so that it can?

That is a different question from whether Erin can afford the house. A budget can say yes while the agreement's own terms make the plan impossible to complete. In Erin's file, the CDLP® sees four things the other two readers are not trained to look for.

  1. 1A deadline built on terms that work against it. The twelve-month deadline assumes Erin can stand on her own by then. Whether she can depends on terms still being drafted, including how long support runs and how it is written. Thirty-six months of support may be fair to both of them and still leave Erin unable to rely on it when the deadline arrives. The CDLP® identifies that conflict while the terms can still be changed.
  2. 2Income the case has not counted. Using family law and tax knowledge, the CDLP® looks for income the case already contains but has not treated as income, so the housing plan is measured against everything Erin actually has.
  3. 3A structure that holds up. Trading retirement for equity may be the strongest way to keep Erin in the house, or it may set her up to fail at month thirty-seven. The CDLP® lays the options side by side, keep, sell, or a deferred sale after the younger child finishes school, so the team chooses with the housing facts in front of it.
  4. 4A fallback that works. If the house has to be sold, the sale provision needs dates and steps both spouses can follow without going back to court.

Each option is tested against the four levers of Mortgage Capacity Mapping™, in order: Feasibility, Affordability, Qualification and Sustainability. One weak link breaks the chain.

What the CDLP® delivers is a written report the whole team can use, and, where it helps, starting language for the drafting attorney to consider. The attorney still decides what goes into the agreement.

Where the three overlap, and where the gap is

The CDFA® and the CDLP® both ask about affordability, and they should. The difference is the question underneath it. The CDFA® asks whether Erin's finances can carry the house over her lifetime. The CDLP® asks whether the plan the agreement describes can actually be carried out, on the agreement's own deadline, given how the other terms are written.

That gap is where agreements come back to court. Everyone did their job, the agreement was signed, and twelve months later the plan cannot be completed.

  Attorney CDFA® CDLP®
The question Is it fair, and is it enforceable? Can the client afford the long-term financial picture? Can the housing plan be carried out as written?
Reads the file for Rights, remedies and drafting Cash flow, retirement and tax effects Gaps in the terms that will block the housing plan
Delivers The agreement Financial projections and analysis A divorce mortgage planning report and starting language to consider
Serves One client One client, or both as a neutral One spouse, both spouses jointly, or both as a Certified Divorce Housing Neutral™

Bringing in a CDLP® is not bringing in a lender

The most common hesitation we hear from attorneys is simple: why bring a loan officer into my case? The answer is that a CDLP® does two different kinds of work, and the first one is not a loan.

Divorce mortgage planning happens while the terms can still be changed. It serves the case, meaning both households and every professional on the file, from one set of housing facts. The work product is a written report. However a CDLP® is engaged depends on the needs of the client. Sometimes the honest answer is that the plan will not work, and that is a legitimate result.

Divorce loan origination comes after the terms are written. It serves one borrower, and its work product is a closed loan.

The published CDLP® Practice Standards keep the two apart. Advisory services and origination are distinct channels, and recommendations made in an advisory engagement must remain independent of any origination relationship. When a CDLP® serves as a Certified Divorce Housing Neutral™, there is no second engagement at all: the neutral does not make a loan to either spouse.

When a CDLP® belongs in the file

A CDLP® belongs in more files than most people expect, because the house is rarely the only housing decision in the case.

Keeping the house is the obvious one. Selling is the one that gets missed. When the house is sold, one or both spouses will often buy again, and the same terms that would trip up a refinance can trip up the purchase: how support is written, how long it runs, and which debts each spouse takes. The right moment is before those terms are drafted, and the reason is specific. Once the agreement is signed, they are fixed. If they work against either spouse's next home, the only way to fix them is to go back to the table or back to court.

In Erin's file, a CDLP® brought in at the draft stage could have shown the team, before anyone signed, that the twelve-month deadline and the thirty-six months of support were working against each other. The attorneys would still have decided what to do about it. They would have decided with the facts in front of them.

The question for a family law professional is not whether a CDLP® can close a loan. It is whether the case is better with one on the file. You can find a CDLP® near you in the CDLP® directory.

About the author

Jody Bruns, CDLP®, is the President and Founder of the Divorce Lending Association and the creator of the CDLP® and REM-S™ designations. She has more than 35 years in mortgage and finance, still practices as a divorce mortgage planner, and has trained more than 12,000 professionals across family law, mediation, the judiciary, financial planning, real estate and mortgage.

The Divorce Lending Association has been advancing divorce mortgage planning as a professional discipline since 2011. It publishes practice standards and a code of ethics, and maintains a public national directory of CDLP® professionals.

This article is general information for professionals. It is not legal, tax or financial advice.

Sources

Post A Comment